github-pr-control-mcpv1.0.1

Tools

8 tools exercised — 0 functionally verified, 8 structurally verified (need real credentials)

verified by execution · unverifiable — the tool executed but needs real credentials or data to confirm success; this never counts against the server · failed — the evidence contradicts the claim · — not applicable (e.g. no required parameters to probe)

Lens

Startup & registration

The server was installed, built, and started in an isolated sandbox; registered tools were cross-checked against the documentation.

• MCP server starts and responds to tools/list

  Server started; 8 tool(s) registered: list_prs, get_pr, get_pr_diff, list_pr_comments, post_review_comment, submit_review, add_labels, request_changes.

• README documents every registered tool

  All 8 registered tools appear in the README.

Lens

Protocol compliance

MCP handshake, identity, capabilities, a clean stdio channel, and shutdown behavior — observed, not assumed.

• Implements the MCP initialize handshake

  Responded with protocolVersion 2024-11-05.

• Declares server identity (serverInfo)

  serverInfo: github-pr-control-mcp v1.0.1.

• Declares the tools capability

  capabilities.tools declared during initialize.

• Keeps stdout clean for JSON-RPC (no log noise on the protocol channel)

  Every stdout line parsed as JSON-RPC.

• Shuts down cleanly when the client disconnects (stdin closed)

  Process exited on its own after stdin closed.

Lens

Tool schemas

Every registered tool inspected for a description and a well-formed, typed input schema.

• Tool `list_prs` declares a valid, typed input schema

  Described, inputSchema is a typed object (8 parameter(s)).

• Tool `get_pr` declares a valid, typed input schema

  Described, inputSchema is a typed object (3 parameter(s)).

• Tool `get_pr_diff` declares a valid, typed input schema

  Described, inputSchema is a typed object (5 parameter(s)).

• Tool `list_pr_comments` declares a valid, typed input schema

  Described, inputSchema is a typed object (6 parameter(s)).

• Tool `post_review_comment` declares a valid, typed input schema

  Described, inputSchema is a typed object (10 parameter(s)).

• Tool `submit_review` declares a valid, typed input schema

  Described, inputSchema is a typed object (5 parameter(s)).

• Tool `add_labels` declares a valid, typed input schema

  Described, inputSchema is a typed object (4 parameter(s)).

• Tool `request_changes` declares a valid, typed input schema

  Described, inputSchema is a typed object (4 parameter(s)).

Lens

Tool execution

Every tool actually called with inputs generated from its own schema. This is the part a badge cannot fake.

• Tool `list_prs` responds to a schema-valid call without crashing

  Responded to the call; server stayed up.

• Tool `list_prs` returns a successful result for a schema-generated input

  Executed but returned a tool error: "Bad credentials - https://docs.github.com/rest" — confirming success needs real credentials/data (structurally verified only).

• Tool `get_pr` responds to a schema-valid call without crashing

  Responded to the call; server stayed up.

• Tool `get_pr` returns a successful result for a schema-generated input

  Executed but returned a tool error: "Bad credentials - https://docs.github.com/rest" — confirming success needs real credentials/data (structurally verified only).

• Tool `get_pr_diff` responds to a schema-valid call without crashing

  Responded to the call; server stayed up.

• Tool `get_pr_diff` returns a successful result for a schema-generated input

  Executed but returned a tool error: "Bad credentials - https://docs.github.com/rest" — confirming success needs real credentials/data (structurally verified only).

• Tool `list_pr_comments` responds to a schema-valid call without crashing

  Responded to the call; server stayed up.

• Tool `list_pr_comments` returns a successful result for a schema-generated input

  Executed but returned a tool error: "Bad credentials - https://docs.github.com/rest" — confirming success needs real credentials/data (structurally verified only).

• Tool `post_review_comment` responds to a schema-valid call without crashing

  Responded to the call; server stayed up.

• Tool `post_review_comment` returns a successful result for a schema-generated input

  Executed but returned a tool error: "Bad credentials - https://docs.github.com/rest" — confirming success needs real credentials/data (structurally verified only).

• Tool `submit_review` responds to a schema-valid call without crashing

  Responded to the call; server stayed up.

• Tool `submit_review` returns a successful result for a schema-generated input

  Executed but returned a tool error: "Bad credentials - https://docs.github.com/rest" — confirming success needs real credentials/data (structurally verified only).

• Tool `add_labels` responds to a schema-valid call without crashing

  Responded to the call; server stayed up.

• Tool `add_labels` returns a successful result for a schema-generated input

  Executed but returned a tool error: "Bad credentials - https://docs.github.com/rest" — confirming success needs real credentials/data (structurally verified only).

• Tool `request_changes` responds to a schema-valid call without crashing

  Responded to the call; server stayed up.

• Tool `request_changes` returns a successful result for a schema-generated input

  Executed but returned a tool error: "Bad credentials - https://docs.github.com/rest" — confirming success needs real credentials/data (structurally verified only).

Lens

Error handling

Every tool with required parameters called with them missing — a robust server errors gracefully and stays up.

• Tool `list_prs` rejects invalid input gracefully (missing required parameters)

  Returned a proper error and stayed alive.

• Tool `get_pr` rejects invalid input gracefully (missing required parameters)

  Returned a proper error and stayed alive.

• Tool `get_pr_diff` rejects invalid input gracefully (missing required parameters)

  Returned a proper error and stayed alive.

• Tool `list_pr_comments` rejects invalid input gracefully (missing required parameters)

  Returned a proper error and stayed alive.

• Tool `post_review_comment` rejects invalid input gracefully (missing required parameters)

  Returned a proper error and stayed alive.

• Tool `submit_review` rejects invalid input gracefully (missing required parameters)

  Returned a proper error and stayed alive.

• Tool `add_labels` rejects invalid input gracefully (missing required parameters)

  Returned a proper error and stayed alive.

• Tool `request_changes` rejects invalid input gracefully (missing required parameters)

  Returned a proper error and stayed alive.